# Evaluation Guide

### Executive Summary

This guide provides a structured framework for government decision-makers to evaluate whether AskGov aligns with their citizen engagement objectives, technical capabilities, and organizational readiness.

**Key Evaluation Areas:**

1. Strategic Alignment & Value Proposition
2. Technical Feasibility Assessment
3. Cost-Benefit Analysis
4. Risk Assessment & Mitigation
5. Implementation Roadmap

{% hint style="info" %}
**Evaluation Timeline**: Allow 2-4 weeks for a thorough evaluation, including technical proof-of-concept and stakeholder consultations.
{% endhint %}

### 1. Strategic Alignment Assessment

#### 1.1 Problem-Solution Fit

**Current Challenges AskGov Addresses**

| Challenge                  | How AskGov Solves It                    | Impact                                  |
| -------------------------- | --------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------- |
| **Repetitive Inquiries**   | Centralized Q\&A repository with search | 60-80% reduction in duplicate questions |
| **Siloed Information**     | Multi-agency unified platform           | Single source of truth for citizens     |
| **Inconsistent Responses** | Standardized, reviewed answers          | Improved answer quality and trust       |
| **Limited Self-Service**   | 24/7 searchable knowledge base          | Reduced call center load                |
| **No Feedback Loop**       | Built-in citizen feedback system        | Data-driven content improvement         |

#### 1.2 Organizational Readiness Checklist

**Essential Requirements**

* [ ] **Cross-agency Collaboration**: Willingness to share information
* [ ] **Content Ownership**: Clear process for answer approval
* [ ] **Technical Team**: At least 2 developers for deployment/maintenance
* [ ] **Change Management**: Plan for staff training and adoption

**Maturity Indicators**

* [ ] Existing digital services strategy
* [ ] Prior experience with open-source adoption
* [ ] Established content governance processes
* [ ] API integration capabilities
* [ ] Cloud infrastructure experience

#### 1.3 Use Case Validation

**Primary Use Cases**

**Tier 1: High-Value, Immediate Impact**

* Frequently asked questions management
* Reducing call/support center volume
* Improving response consistency
* Enabling 24/7 citizen self-service

**Tier 2: Strategic, Long-term Value**

* Cross-agency knowledge sharing
* Data-driven policy insights
* Proactive citizen communication
* Digital inclusion initiatives

**Tier 3: Advanced Capabilities**

* TBD

### 2. Technical Feasibility Assessment

#### 2.1 Infrastructure Requirements

**Core Components Needed:**

* Application servers (Node.js runtime)
* Database (PostgreSQL or CockroachDB)
* Search engine (Weaviate for vector search)

**Scaling Considerations:**

* Start small and scale based on actual usage
* Most deployments begin with minimal resources
* Monitor performance and adjust as needed

#### 2.2 Technical Capabilities Assessment

Rate your organization's capabilities (1-5 scale):

| Capability                  | Required Level | Your Score | Gap Analysis                      |
| --------------------------- | -------------- | ---------- | --------------------------------- |
| **Node.js Development**     | 3              | \_\_\_     | Training/hiring needed?           |
| **Database Administration** | 3              | \_\_\_     | PostgreSQL/CockroachDB experience |
| **Container Orchestration** | 2              | \_\_\_     | Docker basics sufficient          |
| **Cloud Infrastructure**    | 3              | \_\_\_     | AWS/Azure/GCP experience          |
| **Security Operations**     | 4              | \_\_\_     | Critical for public services      |
| **API Integration**         | 3              | \_\_\_     | For system connectivity           |

#### 2.3 Integration Requirements

**Critical Integrations**

**Authentication & Identity**

* [ ] Government identity provider (SAML/OAuth)
* [ ] Citizen authentication system
* [ ] Single sign-on (SSO) requirements

**Communication Channels**

* [ ] Email service (SMTP)

**Analytics & Monitoring**

* [ ] Web analytics platform
* [ ] Application monitoring

### 3. Cost-Benefit Analysis

#### 3.1 Cost Considerations

**Main Cost Categories:**

* Infrastructure (cloud hosting, databases)
* Implementation (setup, customization, training)
* Ongoing maintenance and support
* Potential enhancements and integrations

**Note:** Actual costs vary significantly based on:

* Population served
* Number of agencies
* Required integrations
* Level of customization
* Existing infrastructure

#### 3.2 Expected Benefits

**Quantifiable Benefits:**

* Reduced call center or support tickets volume
* Staff time savings from reduced duplicate questions
* Faster citizen response times
* Reduced errors from standardized answers

**Qualitative Benefits:**

* Improved citizen satisfaction
* Enhanced government transparency
* Better policy insights from data
* Increased digital service adoption
* Reduced information inequality

#### 3.3 Comparison with Alternatives

| Option                       | Pros                                          | Cons                                                  |
| ---------------------------- | --------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- |
| **AskGov (Self-hosted)**     | Full control, customizable, no vendor lock-in | Requires technical team                               |
| **Commercial Q\&A Platform** | Vendor support, SLA guarantees                | Higher cost, less flexible, data sovereignty concerns |
| **Custom Development**       | Exactly what you need                         | Expensive, long timeline, maintenance burden          |
| **Status Quo**               | No change required                            | Continued inefficiencies, citizen frustration         |

### 4. Risk Assessment & Mitigation

#### 4.1 Technical Risks

| Risk                         | Probability | Impact | Mitigation Strategy                    |
| ---------------------------- | ----------- | ------ | -------------------------------------- |
| **Deployment Complexity**    | Medium      | High   | Start with pilot, use quickstart guide |
| **Performance Issues**       | Low         | Medium | Proper sizing, monitoring, caching     |
| **Integration Failures**     | Medium      | Medium | Phased integration, fallback plans     |
| **Security Vulnerabilities** | Low         | High   | Regular updates, security audits       |
| **Data Loss**                | Low         | High   | Backup strategy, disaster recovery     |

#### 4.3 Compliance & Legal Risks

| Risk                    | Assessment Questions         | Mitigation                       |
| ----------------------- | ---------------------------- | -------------------------------- |
| **Data Privacy**        | GDPR/privacy law compliance? | Privacy-by-design implementation |
| **Records Management**  | Retention policy alignment?  | Configure retention rules        |
| **Open Source License** | MIT license acceptable?      | Legal review, attribution        |

### 5. Pilot Program Framework

#### 5.1 Pilot Approach

**Recommended Pilot Structure**

**Duration**: 3-6 months 

**Scope**: 1-2 agencies or departments 

**Users**: 100-1000 citizens 

**Content**: 50-200 high-traffic FAQs

(note: dummy numbers)

**Success Criteria**

**Quantitative Metrics**

* 70% of searches return relevant results
* 60% positive feedback rate
* 30% reduction in related phone inquiries
* 90% system uptime

(note: dummy numbers)

**Qualitative Metrics**

* Positive user feedback
* Staff satisfaction
* Stakeholder support
* Technical team confidence

#### 5.2 Decision Framework

**Go Decision Criteria**

* ✅ Pilot success criteria met
* ✅ Positive ROI projection
* ✅ Stakeholder buy-in secured
* ✅ Technical team ready
* ✅ Funding approved

**No-Go Indicators**

* ❌ Critical technical blockers
* ❌ Negative citizen feedback
* ❌ Insufficient resources
* ❌ Better alternative identified
* ❌ Strategic priority change

### 6. Implementation Readiness Checklist

#### Pre-Implementation Requirements

**Governance & Process**

* [ ] Steering committee formed
* [ ] Content governance process defined
* [ ] Agency coordination mechanism established
* [ ] Success metrics defined
* [ ] Communication plan developed

**Technical Preparation**

* [ ] Infrastructure provisioned
* [ ] Security review completed
* [ ] Backup/recovery plan tested
* [ ] Monitoring configured
* [ ] Integration points identified

**Organizational Readiness**

* [ ] Team trained
* [ ] Support process defined
* [ ] Content ready for migration
* [ ] User documentation prepared
* [ ] Launch plan approved

### 7. Vendor vs Self-Hosting Decision Matrix

| Factor               | Self-Host AskGov | Commercial Vendor | Weight | Your Score |
| -------------------- | ---------------- | ----------------- | ------ | ---------- |
| **Total Cost**       | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐            | ⭐⭐                | 25%    |            |
| **Customization**    | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐            | ⭐⭐                | 20%    |            |
| **Data Sovereignty** | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐            | ⭐                 | 20%    |            |
| **Time to Deploy**   | ⭐⭐⭐              | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐             | 15%    |            |
| **Vendor Support**   | ⭐⭐               | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐             | 10%    |            |
| **Scalability**      | ⭐⭐⭐⭐             | ⭐⭐⭐⭐              | 5%     |            |
| **Innovation Pace**  | ⭐⭐⭐⭐             | ⭐⭐⭐               | 5%     |            |

### Next Steps

#### If Proceeding with AskGov:

1. **Technical Proof of Concept**
   * Follow Quickstart Guide
   * Test with real content
   * Validate integrations
2. **Stakeholder Alignment**
   * Present evaluation findings
   * Secure funding and resources
   * Get formal approval
3. **Implementation Planning**
   * Review deployment guide
   * Plan customizations (Component Customization)
   * Develop training materials

#### If Not Proceeding:

1. Document lessons learned
2. Consider alternatives
3. Revisit in 6-12 months
4. Monitor AskGov evolution

***

{% hint style="success" %}
**Need Help with Evaluation?**

* **Technical Questions**: Review our Quickstart Guide
* **Architecture Concerns**: See Infrastructure Guidance
* **Security Assessment**: Check Security Guide
* **Legal Review**: Read Legal and Compliance
  {% endhint %}


---

# Agent Instructions: Querying This Documentation

If you need additional information that is not directly available in this page, you can query the documentation dynamically by asking a question.

Perform an HTTP GET request on the current page URL with the `ask` query parameter:

```
GET https://international.open.gov.sg/self-hosting/askgov/evaluation-guide.md?ask=<question>
```

The question should be specific, self-contained, and written in natural language.
The response will contain a direct answer to the question and relevant excerpts and sources from the documentation.

Use this mechanism when the answer is not explicitly present in the current page, you need clarification or additional context, or you want to retrieve related documentation sections.